
TURKEY: HOT & FAST OR LOW & SLOW?
Red alert: Thanksgiving is one week away. One of the biggest cooking days of the entire year is nearly upon us. So it better be lit (pun intended).
Red alert: Thanksgiving is one week away. One of the biggest cooking days of the entire year is nearly upon us.
In seven days, several minivans full of relatives pull into your driveway. Which we should all be grateful for. But then the men walk right past the dining room, and head straight for the backyard to judge your smoker…
So it better be lit (pun intended).
And somebody (usually the uncle who has never lit a fire in his life) is going to squint at the thermometer and say it…
“Isn’t that a little hot?”
Sooooo, let’s settle it now. Because this week, the BBQ world needs to pick sides.

TEAM HOT
Steven Raichlen has written 30-plus books on live fire. If that name doesn’t ring a bell, give the man a Google and some respect.
His take: smoke-roast your turkey at 325 to 350°F, not the 225 to 250 you’d run for a brisket.
Go low and risk the skin turning to rubber. His other rule: keep the smoke light. “Let the turkey taste like turkey.”
Team hot wants their turkey looking like this:

On the other hand…
TEAM LOW
On the other side of the thermometer, Derrick Riches runs his pellet grill at 275°F and lets a 15-pounder ride for about 7 hours, with a spritz and a butter baste along the way.
Derrick’s argument: low and slow leaves you with a tender, juicy bird.
And maybe he’s got a point. Smoke doesn’t really get through at a high temp…
Team low is worried that a too-hot turkey will look like this:

OUR CALL
Here’s where the Dead Meat Society lands: we say run it hot.
Thing is, turkey isn’t brisket. There’s no collagen to melt, no stall to push through, and no reason to babysit a lean bird all day.
The longer it sits, the drier that breast can get. And skin that never crisps is just a smoky raincoat.
Our CMO’s method (scroll down a bit to the recipe) runs the grill at 325 to 350°F with butter under the skin, and a 12 to 14 lb bird is done in 3 to 4 hours. Still plenty of smoke. Plus skin that people will surely fight over.
A few numbers in case you aren’t a turkey expert yet:
Run 325 to 350°F, indirect, with apple, cherry, or pecan. Leave the mesquite in the garage.
Pull it when the breast hits 160°F and the thighs hit 175 to 180°F. The rest carries the breast to 165.
Rest it 30 to 45 minutes under a loose foil tent. Wrap it tight and you will accidentally steam the skin you just crisped up.
Feeding a crowd? Two 12 lb birds beat one 20 pounder every time. (Bonus: four drumsticks.)
Still need the buying, thawing, and brining part? Our CMO covered all of it in Turkey 101 this week.

BEFORE YOU ARGUE
And before you low-and-slow guys stand up and complain… yes, 275 makes a fine turkey. We’re not calling it wrong.
We’re just calling it four extra hours for skin nobody wants to eat…
YOUR ASSIGNMENT
Use the oven another day. Light the grill. Smoke the pies. Run it hot.
And when the uncle asks if it’s a little hot, hand him a drumstick and tell him you’re thankful for him.
Then post your bird in the Facebook group so the rest of us can judge it too.
Need the full plan of attack? Keep reading. We’ve got everything covered this week.